A new report by the former cabinet minister Alan Milburn will call for employer National Insurance (NI) contributions on workers under the age of 25 to be gradually reduced, arguing that the tax burden is pricing young people out of the labour market. The report is due to be published on Tuesday and has already prompted debate among small business owners, some of whom say the jobs market for young people has become so difficult that parents are effectively paying their children's wages.

The proposal lands at an awkward moment for the government. Employer NI was raised to 15% and the point at which firms start paying it was cut sharply in April, measures designed to raise billions for public services but which business groups warned would raise the cost of hiring. A youth-specific relief would, in effect, reverse part of that calculation for the youngest workers.

What the report proposes

According to early reports, Milburn recommends that the government phase down the employer rate of National Insurance for under-25s over a number of years rather than introducing an overnight cut. The logic is straightforward: employer NI is a tax on jobs, and it is highest, in relative terms, for the lower-paid, entry-level roles that young people typically fill. Gradually reducing it would, in theory, make hiring a 19-year-old trainee cheaper without touching the employee's take-home pay.

Britain has been here before. In 2015 the government abolished employer NI for workers under 21, and a year later extended a similar exemption to apprentices under 25. A regional employer NI holiday for new businesses was also trialled from 2010. Milburn's contribution is to argue that the remaining gap — all under-25s, across all sectors — should now be closed at a time when youth unemployment and the number of young people not in education, employment or training have both been rising.

'Parents are offering to pay kids' wages'

The argument is not only macroeconomic. A salon owner interviewed by the BBC described a labour market in which the cost of employing a young person has become a family matter, with parents offering to cover part of their child's wages to persuade a business to take them on.

'Parents are offering to pay kids' wages.'

The anecdote captures something sharper than a tax argument. In low-margin, service-sector businesses — hairdressing, hospitality, retail — the employer NI bill on an entry-level wage can be the difference between taking on an extra pair of hands and not. When parents step in to bridge that gap, the burden of youth unemployment shifts onto households, and access to opportunity becomes a question of family wealth.

That framing also explains why the story has travelled so widely. Coverage across the BBC, Yahoo and MSN has tended to lead with the human detail — parents subsidising their children's jobs — before getting to the policy substance, a reflection of how abstract payroll taxes become vivid only when attached to a named business owner.

The case for and against

Supporters of a youth NI relief make three arguments. First, that the under-25s are the group most sensitive to hiring costs, because they have the least experience and the shortest track record for employers to assess. Second, that a spell of unemployment early in a career leaves lasting scars on earnings and employment prospects. Third, that previous exemptions — the under-21 and apprentice reliefs — were absorbed without obvious disruption, suggesting the administrative machinery already exists.

Critics counter that payroll tax reliefs are blunt instruments. Employers may simply bank the saving rather than create new roles — the 'deadweight' problem that has dogged every employment subsidy ever designed. Others warn that a youth exemption could encourage firms to substitute young, cheaper workers for older ones, or to churn staff to keep within the age threshold. And there is the fiscal question: a relief of this kind across all under-25s would be expensive at a time when the public finances are already stretched, with the Treasury unlikely to sign off on anything that resembles an unfunded tax cut.

A political test for a familiar voice

Milburn is a distinctive figure to make this case. A former Labour health secretary who has since built a reputation as a government-commissioned reviewer on social mobility, he has spent much of his post-frontbench career arguing that opportunity is too often rationed by background. His intervention is likely to be welcomed by business lobby groups and by employer organisations that have campaigned for years against the cumulative cost of hiring — but it may sit less comfortably with a government that has staked its fiscal credibility on tight spending settlements.

The timing also matters practically. Any reform to employer NI would have to wait for a Budget, and gradual phase-ins are attractive to chancellors precisely because the full cost arrives years after the announcement.

What happens next

The report's publication on Tuesday will set the terms of the argument rather than settle it. Expect business groups to seize on the findings as evidence that the current employer NI settlement is suppressing hiring, and expect the Treasury to respond with a reminder of the fiscal inheritance. What is less easy to dismiss is the anecdotal evidence from the shop floor: when a salon owner says parents are offering to pay their children's wages, the case for looking again at the cost of hiring a young person is already made.